top of page
Search


H2H 4. 201. Ken Rex McElroy. It Happened in Plain Sight.
July 10, 1981, Skidmore, Missouri. A man climbs into the cab of his pick-up truck after leaving the D & G Tavern. He starts the truck....


H2H 4. 200. Beulah Louise Overell and George Bud Gollum. Murder on the Mary E.
March 15, 1947, Newport Harbor, California. Walter and Beulah Overell are enjoying a night on their yacht the Mary E. With their...


H2H 4. 199. Felix Vail and the Gone Girls.
Mary Horton, Sharon Hensley and Annette Craver. Three beautiful women who either turn up dead or simply vanish from the earth. They were...


H2H 4. 198. Skip Welch, Blind Johnnie Richmond and Theresa Bier. Murder, Meth and the Mystery of Bigfoot.
June 1, 1987, Fresno, California. 16-year-old, Theresa Ann Bier has made plans to skip school and go on an adventure into the Sierra...


H2H 4. 186. Chuck Morgan. Mystery, Murder and Maybe the Mob.
June 18, 1977, Tucson, Arizona. 39 -year-old Chuck Morgan is found lying near his new car, 40 miles west of his home—11 days after he...


H2H 4. 182. The Alphabet Murders
In the early 70’s, over than span of two years, three young girls were taken in broad daylight just blocks from their homes in Rochester,...


H2H 4. 179. Suzanne and Barry Morphew. Unraveling a Mystery of Marriage and Murder.
May 10, 2019. It’s Mother’s Day, and mom Suzanne Morphew is home while her husband Barry is an hour and a half away on a job site. When...


H2H 4. 173. Roscoe "Fatty" Arbuckle and the Death of Virginia Rappe
September 5th, Labor Day weekend, 1921. Silent movie star and comedian Roscoe Fatty Arbuckle is in San Francisco with his buddies for a...


H2H 4. 170. Jerry Lee Lewis and his Fifth Wife, Shawn Stephens. The Killer? Or the Killer.
He was a man bigger than life. A rock n roller that made girls weak in the knees and preachers clutch their Bibles. But was he a killer?...


H2H 4. 163. Lana Turner and Johnny Stompanado. The Gangster, the Daughter and the Knife.
April 4, 1958, Oscar nominated actress Lana Turner is fighting with her boyfriend—a man with known connections to the mob. In the house,...


H2H 4.162. Darlie Routier. Guilty? Or Innocent on Death Row?
June 6, 1996, Rowlett, Texas. Two small boys and their mother are sleeping in the family room for the night. The mother wakes, and a man...


H2H 4. 153. Edward Hall and Eleanor Mills. The Preacher, the Choir Singer and the Pig Woman.
September 16, 1922 New Brunswick New Jersey. A married man and his teenage girlfriend discover two bodies on a lover’s lane near an...


H2H 3. 151. Gloria Pointer. Waiting for Justice.
December 6, 1984. Fourteen year old, Gloria Pointer is walking to school—she’s excited because she's receiving a perfect attendance...


H2H 3. 150. Carl "Charlie" Brandt. Killer Hiding in Plain Sight.
September 2004. Charlie Brandt and his wife Teri have come to Orlando Florida from Big Pine Key. They’ve escaped the wrath of hurricane...


H2H 3. 148 Richard Cottingham. The Torso Killer
From 1967 to 1980, New York City and suburban New Jersey was the playground for a sexual serial killer who would bind, torture, strangle...


H2H 3. 147 The Osage Nation Murders. The Killers of the Flower Moon.
From 1918 to 1931, sixty or more full-blood Osage Native Americans were either murdered or died under mysterious circumstances. Why?...


H2H 3. 138. Casey Pomeroy MacPherson and Caleb Guillory. Poisoned in Paradise or Murder?
December 20, 2018, the island of Anguilla. Six friends are ringing in the new year together, spending time on the beach in Island Harbor....


Herb Baumeister: The Family Man Who Buried His Secrets in the Backyard
In the heart of suburban Indiana, on Fox Hollow Farm, lay the horrifying secrets of Herb Baumeister-a prolific and terrifying serial killer.


H2H 3.127 The Jamison Family Deaths. Mystery or Murder?
October 8, 2009. Bobby and Sherilynn Jamison along with six-year-old daughter Madyson drive thirty miles from their lake home in Eufaula,...


H2H 3. 123. The Unsolved Case of The Freeway Phantom
Between 1971 and 1972, a killer was on the loose in the Washington DC area. He strangled, raped and even stabbed six young...
bottom of page