Buried Beneath Fourth Street: The Murder of Jamie Carroll by Joey Banis or Jeffrey Mundt— Part 1

Published by Hitched 2 Homicide | True Crime Podcast

"There's only three people who truly know what happened in that room that night, and only two of them came out alive." — Barry Baisden, friend of Jamie Carroll

Welcome to Louisville, Kentucky

Louisville, Kentucky is one of those cities that wears its charm on its sleeve. Bourbon distilleries. Derby hats. Cobblestone streets lined with gas lanterns. And tucked just south of the downtown skyline lies a neighborhood that looks like it was plucked straight from a Victorian fever dream — Old Louisville. Grand mansions with stained glass windows and wrap around porches, built by wealthy bourbon barons at the height of the Gilded Age. It is, by every measure, gorgeous.

And in the winter of 2009, beneath the creaking floors of one of its most storied homes, something unspeakable was silently rotting away.

This is the story of James "Jamie" Carroll — hairdresser, drag queen, meth dealer, and a man whose magnetic personality made everyone in the room feel like the most important person alive. It is also the story of Jeffrey "Jase" Mundt and Joseph "Joey" Banis — two men bound together by drugs, obsession, and secrets so dark that even the city's beloved Victorian shadows couldn't keep them buried forever.

Welcome to Hitched 2 Homicide, and welcome to Part One of one of the most disturbing, twisted, and flat-out scandalous true crime cases ever to come out of the Commonwealth of Kentucky.

Pull up a chair. Pour your drink. You're going to want to stay a while.

The Man Behind the Smile: Who Was Jamie Carroll?

Before we go any further, we need to talk about Jamie Carroll — because in cases like this, the victim can sometimes get lost in the drama surrounding his killers. And Jamie Carroll deserves far better than that.

Born and raised in Martin and Floyd County, Kentucky, Jamie was thirty-seven when he died. By day, he was a hairstylist—and a gifted one. A beauty school classmate once wrote about him on his memorial page, saying that his enthusiasm and compassion for his craft were visible in everything he did. "Jamie's personality was magnetic, and his clientele loved him dearly," the classmate wrote. "He could come to school broke and leave school that evening with a pocketful of tip money. He knew how to make money even in school, because he was natural to his profession."

That was Jamie. Natural. Magnetic. Someone who walked into a room and made it brighter just by being in it.

But when the sun went down, Jamie traded his scissors for sequins. He performed on Louisville's drag scene under the name Ronica Reed — a larger-than-life persona that matched the larger-than-life man behind the makeup. Louisville's LGBTQ+ community knew Jamie. Loved Jamie. He was one of their own.

He also had a side hustle that would, ultimately, put him in the crosshairs of two very dangerous men. Jamie dealt methamphetamine. It's a fact that doesn't define him, but it matters to the story — because it's what first made him valuable to the couple at 1435 South 4th Street, and what may have made him a target.

Most heartbreakingly of all? When Jamie Carroll vanished, no one reported him missing. He had a pending court date in a drug case that he simply never showed up for. His family, when eventually contacted, believed he was incarcerated. It would be seven months before anyone looked hard enough to find him — and by then, the truth waiting beneath that Louisville mansion would shock a city to its core.

The Mansion on South 4th Street: A House With a History

The property at 1435 South Fourth Street in Old Louisville is the kind of house that stops people in their tracks. An 8,000-square-foot Victorian mansion dating back to 1898, it sits across from the entrance to one of Louisville's famous pedestrian walking courts — those intimate, tree-lined lanes designed to bring a bit of old-world London charm to the American South. The home has imposing architecture, beautiful parquet floors, a dozen bedrooms, and deep in its belly, an old wine cellar with a dirt floor.

At various points in its long history, the building reportedly served as a sanatorium. Neighbors said the atmosphere around the property was ghostlike — quiet, still, as though no one really lived there.

But someone did. And that someone was Jeffrey Steven Mundt.

Jeffrey "Jase" Mundt: The Man Who Looked Good on Paper

On paper — and Jeff Mundt spent a great deal of time making sure the paper looked immaculate — he was everything you'd expect from a respectable Louisville professional.

A native of the city, he attended Atherton High School, swam competitively at Lakeside Swim Club, and then went on to earn a computer science degree from Indiana University. He followed that with a master's from Northwestern University near Chicago, where he later oversaw a significant university-wide IT overhaul. Suits. No criminal record. The kind of guy whose parents showed up to court to sit in his corner. In May 2009, he returned to Louisville to work in the information technology department at the University of Louisville.

His co-workers described him as friendly and hardworking. He was open about being a gay man, but whatever happened behind his closed doors, he kept private. Very private. As Louisville Metro Police Sergeant Jon Lesher would later put it: "Jeff lets friends and co-workers know that he has an alternative lifestyle, that he is a gay male; but what happens behind his closed doors, it's a nightmare."

Because behind those closed doors, the polished IT professional had what investigators described as a voracious appetite for violent sex and crystal meth. He had purchased the crumbling Victorian mansion on South 4th Street and had grand plans to restore it into a bed and breakfast. Instead, it would become something else entirely.

In October 2009, Jeff Mundt logged onto Adam4Adam — a gay adult dating site — and found a match.

Joseph "Joey" Banis: The Man the System Knew Too Well

If Jeff Mundt was everything that looked good on paper, Joseph "Joey" Richard Banis was everything that didn't.

Born in 1972, Joey had spent much of his adult life accumulating a criminal record that read like a cautionary tale. Multiple felony convictions. Drug charges. Theft. In Kentucky, the legal system had labeled him a Persistent Felony Offender — a classification that follows a person like a shadow, automatically escalating the consequences of every future run-in with the law. He had owned a club in downtown Louisville at one point, but by the fall of 2009, that chapter was closed. Joey had just walked out of prison on drug-related charges and was trying to figure out what came next.

What came next was Jeff Mundt.

The two connected online in the fall of 2009, and despite — or perhaps because of — their wildly different backgrounds, the chemistry was immediate. Within just a few weeks of meeting, Joey Banis moved into the sprawling mansion at 1435 South 4th Street.

"Both of them, Mundt and Banis, were the two most diabolical, intelligent individuals I have ever met," Assistant County Attorney Josh Schneider would later tell reporters.

But here is where the story gets complicated — because Joey Banis didn't just find Jeff Mundt on Adam4Adam in the fall of 2009.

He also found Jamie Carroll.

A Love Triangle With No Good Angles

Shortly after his release from prison in September 2009, Joey Banis connected with Jamie Carroll online — the same type of gay men's dating website where he would soon meet Mundt. According to what would later emerge in court, the two became physically and emotionally involved. They were, by Banis's own account to police, in a sexual relationship.

Then Banis met Mundt and, within weeks, moved into the South 4th Street mansion. The two became a couple. Exclusive, by all accounts.

But Jamie Carroll didn't disappear from the picture. Because Jamie had something both men wanted: methamphetamine. He was their dealer. Which meant he was still very much present in their lives, even as Banis established his new relationship with Mundt.

According to Banis's later statements to police, Mundt was aware of the prior relationship between Banis and Jamie. And according to those same statements, Mundt didn't care for it one bit. "Mr. Mundt didn't care for Mr. Carroll," Banis told detectives, in what may be the understatement of the decade.

The jealousy, whatever its source, was simmering. It just needed the right night to boil over.

December 2009: The Night Jamie Walked Into That House

The exact date varies slightly depending on the source, but what is documented is that sometime in early-to-mid December 2009 — the Kentucky Supreme Court would later place the gathering in mid December; one source identifies the night as December 14th — James "Jamie" Carroll drove to the Victorian mansion on South 4th Street in Old Louisville.

He went of his own accord. He knew both men. He'd been there before. He came bearing methamphetamine and the promise of a wild night among people he considered, at the very least, familiar.

What no one outside those walls will ever know with certainty is exactly what happened once that door closed behind him.

What we do know comes from two men who both walked out alive — and who told two very different stories.

Two Stories, One Dead Man

Joey Banis's version: At some point during the night, while he was watching pornography in another part of the home, Mundt and Jamie were together in the bedroom. Banis told detectives that Mundt had earlier turned to him and asked, "Do you think anyone would miss Jamie? We could take his drugs." Banis claimed he didn't understand what Mundt meant at the time. Then, when Jamie returned to the bedroom after retrieving more meth, Mundt produced a knife and stabbed him. Jamie cried out — "Joey, Joey, help me" — before Mundt grabbed a .38 Smith & Wesson revolver and shot him twice. Banis told police that Mundt then pointed the gun at him and threatened to kill him too if he didn't help dispose of the body.

Jeffrey Mundt's version: He and Jamie were in the bedroom together when Banis suddenly attacked without warning. Mundt claimed that Banis slashed Jamie's throat with a knife while Jamie screamed Banis's name. Then Banis shot him with a revolver. According to Mundt, Banis then administered a date rape drug — GHB — to him to keep him compliant, threatened to kill him and his family if he breathed a word, and forced him to help clean up and bury the body.

Both men agreed on these facts: Jamie Carroll was stabbed and shot. He died in that bedroom. The Kentucky Supreme Court, in reviewing the case, described the gathering as "a drug-infused ménage à trois" that went violently wrong. The medical examiner would later determine that Carroll sustained multiple stab wounds — three of which were fatal — along with a gunshot wound to the neck.

What happened next required time, planning, and a stomach for horror.

What They Did Next

Whatever combination of willingness and coercion drove the two men forward, they worked together to make Jamie Carroll disappear.

They stripped his body of his valuables. They cleaned his remains with mineral spirits. They beat his body with a sledgehammer — the Kentucky Supreme Court's own documents record this — compressing it so it would fit into what came next. They bound him with twine and doused him in lime.

Then they took him deep into the bowels of the house — down to the old wine cellar in the basement, where the floor was bare earth. With a pick and a shovel, they dug. When the hole was deep enough, they lowered Jamie Carroll — wrapped in bedsheets, sealed inside a 50-gallon Rubbermaid storage container secured with tape and expanding foam to trap the smell — into the ground.

They covered it over with hard clay and mud. And then they went back upstairs.

"The interment of this pitiful coffin into the dirt rendered the dastardly deed complete," the Kentucky Supreme Court later wrote, "and the secret forever laid to rest. Or so it seemed."

For the next several months, Jeffrey Mundt and Joey Banis continued to live in that house. They ate their meals above his grave. They slept above his grave. They went on with their lives.

Nobody came looking for Jamie Carroll. Nobody reported him missing.

Unraveling: The Chicago Arrest

The first crack appeared not in Louisville, but in Chicago.

In April 2010, roughly four months after Jamie Carroll's murder, Mundt and Banis traveled to the Windy City and checked into the Hyatt Regency. When they approached a hotel doorman to exchange a $100 bill, the bill was flagged as counterfeit. Police were called. When officers searched the men and their vehicle, they found $55,000 in counterfeit currency, date rape drugs, handguns, fake IDs, handcuffs, meth pipes, and more.

Federal authorities became involved. The Secret Service was called in — counterfeiting is their jurisdiction. The couple's laptops and hard drives were seized, containing nearly a million files whose contents, to this day, have never been fully disclosed publicly.

Here's the critical detail: Chicago police didn't know about a murdered man buried in a basement in Louisville. The two men were arrested on counterfeiting charges, bonded out of Cook County Jail, and returned to Louisville — where Jamie Carroll was still waiting in the ground.

But the clock was ticking.

June 17, 2010: The 911 Call That Changed Everything

By June 2010, whatever fragile peace had existed between Mundt and Banis had shattered completely. Nobody is quite sure what ignited the final confrontation — whether Mundt was genuinely planning to go to police about the body, or whether Banis had simply reached a breaking point. What is known is that the evening of June 17, 2010 ended with Mundt barricaded in his bathroom, phone pressed to his ear, calling 911 in a state of pure terror.

"My boyfriend is attacking me," Mundt told the dispatcher. "He's trying to get into the room where I'm hiding. Please. He's breaking down the door."

He told dispatchers that Banis had a knife. That he was trying to break through the bedroom door with a hammer. That he feared for his life.

Louisville Metro Police responded to the residence at 1435 South 4th Street at approximately 9 p.m. Officers arrived, managed the scene, and placed Joey Banis in custody on suspicion of domestic violence.

Then they put him in the back of a squad car — and everything changed.

"Before You Take Me to Jail..."

In the back of that police cruiser, with the weight of nearly seven months pressing down on him, Joey Banis made a decision.

He asked to speak to a detective.

What he said next stopped the officers cold. According to Louisville Metro Police Sgt. Trey McKnight, who later recounted the moment, Banis told them plainly: "Before you take me to jail, I need to talk to a detective, because there's a body buried in our basement."

A body. In the basement. At 1435 South 4th Street.

He gave them a name: Jamie Carroll.

He told them Carroll was a drug dealer. That he and Mundt had invited him over in November — some accounts say December — to get drugs. That all three of them had been involved sexually. And that what happened next had ended with a dead man under the basement floor.

Detectives were initially skeptical. The story was bizarre, the circumstances chaotic. But when they contacted Carroll's family and learned they had believed he was simply incarcerated — and when a check with Lexington police found no record of him in the prison system — the detectives grew very serious very quickly.

They brought Mundt in for questioning too. At first, he told them he knew nothing. Then, slowly, the story began to pour out of him — and like Banis, he pointed every finger he had squarely at his boyfriend.

But first, there was a hole to dig.

The Dirt Doesn't Lie

Police returned to the mansion on South 4th Street with shovels.

Down in the old wine cellar, beneath feet of hard-packed clay and mud, they found it: a large plastic storage container, sealed with tape and foam, buried four to six feet beneath the basement floor.

Inside was what remained of James "Jamie" Carroll — decomposed beyond recognition after nearly seven months underground, but identifiable. His death was ruled a homicide. The cause: multiple stab wounds to the throat and chest, and a gunshot wound.

Louisville had its body.

Now it needed its answers.

Both Jeffrey Mundt and Joey Banis were taken into custody and charged with first-degree murder, robbery, and tampering with physical evidence. Each man had told a story. Each man had blamed the other. And somewhere between those two stories was the truth about what really happened to Jamie Carroll on that December night in 2009.

Coming Up in Part Two...

In Part Two of Buried Beneath Fourth Street, we go inside the courtrooms. Two separate trials. Two men pointing at each other across years of legal maneuvering. A videotaped confession that would become the pivotal piece of evidence in the entire case. And the final verdicts that left Louisville — and the true crime world — asking whether justice was truly served.

Only one man was convicted of murder. Only one is still behind bars. And the question of what really happened that night in Old Louisville may never be fully answered.

Don't miss it.

Hitched 2 Homicide is hosted by thriller author Kris Calvert and Emmy®-nominated composer Rob Pottorf. We cover real cases from around the world — cold cases, killers, con artists, and crimes that shook nations — and we do it together. Til death do us part.

Subscribe wherever you listen to podcasts.

START KRIS CALVERT'S BOOKS TODAY FOR FREE

Sources used for this podcast:

Web, articles, and general sources

A&E. (n.d.). After the First 48, season 4, episode 14. In After the First 48. A&E. https://play.aetv.com/shows/after-the-first-48/season-4/episode-14

Adam4Adam. (n.d.). Adam4Adam [Website]. https://www.adam4adam.com

A&E. (2026, February 16). Who really killed Jamie Carroll? A&E. https://www.aetv.com/articles/jamie-carroll-murdered-louisville

Biography.com Editors. (2026, February 18). Where are “Glitterball City” killers Joe Banis and Jeffrey Mundt now? Biography. https://www.biography.com/crime/a70328778/jamie-carroll-murder-joe-banis-jeffrey-mundt

Domine, D. (2021, October 4). A lover’s quarrel, a dilapidated mansion, and a body in the basement. CrimeReads. https://crimereads.com/david-domine-a-lovers-quarrel-a-dilapidated-mansion-and-a-body-in-the-basement/

Find a Grave. (n.d.). James Daniel “Jamie” Carroll. Find a Grave. https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/58672022/james_daniel-carroll

Find a Grave. (n.d.). Mary Pauline Boren. Find a Grave. https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/146758987/mary-pauline-boren

Go To Louisville. (n.d.). Historic Old Louisville walking tour. Louisville Tourism. https://www.gotolouisville.com/directory/historic-old-louisville-walking-tour/

HelloLouisvilleKY. (n.d.). Louisville unearthed: Our city began as a settlement on a now-submerged island. HelloLouisvilleKY. https://www.hellolouisvilleky.com/blog/louisville-unearthed-our-city-began-as-a-settlement-on-a-now-submerged-island

Kentucky Derby. (n.d.). KentuckyDerby.com [Official site]. https://www.kentuckyderby.com/

Moms and Mysteries. (2026, February 5). The James Carroll murder: HBO’s “Glitterball City” story. Moms and Mysteries. https://www.momsandmysteries.com/blog/james-carroll-murder-hbo-glitterball-city-true-story

Oxygen. (2023). Jeffrey Mundt and Joey Banis (Season 17, Episode 1) [TV series episode]. In Snapped: Killer Couples. Oxygen. https://www.oxygen.com/snapped-killer-couples/season-17/episode-1/jeffrey-mundt-and-joey-banis

Oxygen. (2024, July 17). Who killed Jamie Carroll? Jeffrey Mundt, Joey Banis case explained. Oxygen. https://www.oxygen.com/snapped-killer-couples/crime-news/who-killed-jamie-carroll-jeffrey-mundt-joey-banis-case-explained

People Staff. (2026, February 20). Couple buried man in basement, then accused each other of murder. People. https://people.com/glitterball-city-murder-jeffrey-mundt-joseph-banis-accused-each-other-11910878

People Staff. (2026, February 20). Where are Jeffrey Mundt and Joseph Banis now? Inside the lovers who accused each other of murder. People. https://people.com/where-are-jeffrey-mundt-and-joseph-banis-now-11909596

Reddit user u/JosAlwyn. (2024). Joe growing up [Online forum post]. Reddit. https://www.reddit.com/r/JosAlwyn/comments/1pgx5rp/joe_growing_up/

Reddit user u/RedditCrimeCommunity. (2022, June 20). Graveyard love: The murder of Jaime Carroll [Online forum post]. Reddit. https://www.reddit.com/r/RedditCrimeCommunity/comments/vh3mlx/graveyard_love_the_murder_of_jaime_carroll/

StyleBlueprint. (n.d.). Walk Old Louisville. StyleBlueprint. https://styleblueprint.com/everyday/walk-old-louisville/

The Courier‑Journal. (2014, August 29). Jeffrey Mundt, who helped bury body in basement, released from prison. The Courier‑Journal. https://www.courier-journal.com/story/news/crime/2014/08/29/jeffrey-mundt-helped-bury-body-basement-released-prison/14828233/

The Courier‑Journal. (2021, July 26). Author details dark history of Old Louisville Victorian mansion [Photo gallery]. The Courier‑Journal. https://www.courier-journal.com/picture-gallery/news/local/2021/07/26/author-details-dark-history-of-old-louisville-victorian-mansion/8063608002/

The Courier‑Journal. (2024, April 28). Churchill Downs and Louisville during the first Kentucky Derby in 1875 [Photo gallery]. The Courier‑Journal. https://www.courier-journal.com/picture-gallery/entertainment/events/kentucky-derby/2024/04/28/churchill-down-and-louisville-during-the-first-kentucky-derby-in-1875/73291478007/

Tumblr. (n.d.). Findingyourinmate: Hello, my name is Joey, I am… Tumblr. https://www.tumblr.com/nightskymth/169979401898/findingyourinmate-hello-my-name-is-joey-i-am

USA Today. (2013, May 30). Man acquitted of murder in Ky. love‑triangle case. USA Today. https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2013/05/30/man-acquitted-love-triangle-case/2371581/

Vanity Fair. (2026, February 19). The cocreators of RuPaul’s Drag Race bring a shocking killing to HBO’s Murder in Glitterball City. Vanity Fair. https://www.vanityfair.com/hollywood/story/new-true-crime-february-hbo-murder-glitterball-city

Warner Bros. Discovery. (n.d.). Jeffrey Mundt and Joey Banis Christmas tree art [Promotional still]. https://press.wbd.com/us/image/gb-artjoey-jeff-xmas-tree-0000?language_content_entity=en

Wikipedia contributors. (n.d.). Old Louisville. In Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Retrieved April 21, 2026, from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Old_Louisville

Wikipedia contributors. (n.d.). New Orleans (steamboat). In Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. Retrieved April 21, 2026, from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Orleans_%28steamboat%29#/media/File:First_Boat_Built_on_the_Western_Waters,_1812.jpg

WDRB. (2013, June 11). Banis sentenced to life behind bars. WDRB. https://www.wdrb.com/news/banis-sentenced-to-life-behind-bars/article_2d95fe7e-3431-5843-aa37-e406df99f800.html

WDRB. (2025, November 22). Plea deal gives Joseph Banis life sentence. WDRB. https://www.wdrb.com/news/plea-deal-gives-joseph-banis-life-sentence/article_a2c87bd1-0362-5a5c-9b46-6fbd8c66041d.html

Yahoo Entertainment. (2026, February 20). Where are Jeffrey Mundt and Joseph Banis now? All about Jamie Carroll’s “Glitterball City” killers. Yahoo. https://www.yahoo.com/news/articles/where-jeffrey-mundt-joseph-banis-113000631.html

YouTube. (2015, October 29). Police say case is real “How to Get Away with Murder” [Video]. ABC7 Chicago. https://abc7chicago.com/post/police-say-case-is-real-how-to-get-away-with-murder/1058406/

YouTube. (2026, February 13). HBO documentary explores 2010 Old Louisville murder [Video]. WHAS11. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xKcJ6k2L-AY

10 Minute Murder. (2026, February 22). Jeffrey Mundt and Joseph Banis: The Fourth Street house of horrors. 10MinuteMurder.com. https://www.10minutemurder.com/blog/jeffrey-mundt-and-joseph-banis-the-fourth-street-house-of-horrors/

Dominé, D. (2021). A dark room in Glitter Ball City: Murder, secrets, and scandal in Old Louisville (Kindle ed.). Pegasus Crime. https://www.amazon.com/dp/B093HJGH3Z

Court / official records

Kentucky Department of Corrections. (n.d.). Offender information: Banis, Joseph [KOOL inmate search record]. Retrieved April 21, 2026, from http://kool.corrections.ky.gov/KOOL/Details/106976

Mundt v. Commonwealth, 2013‑CA‑001311‑MR, 2013‑CA‑001331‑MR (Ky. Ct. App. Dec. 5, 2014). https://law.justia.com/cases/kentucky/court-of-appeals/2014/2013-ca-001311-mr.html

TV series / documentary references

A&E. (n.d.). After the First 48 [TV series]. A&E.

A&E. (n.d.). After the First 48: Cold and callous (Season 4, Episode 14) [TV series episode]. In After the First 48. A&E.

HBO. (2026). Murder in Glitterball City [TV documentary series]. HBO.

Oxygen. (2009– ). Snapped: Killer Couples [TV series]. Oxygen.

World of Wonder, & VH1/MTV. (2009– ). RuPaul’s Drag Race [TV series].

Film, TV, and other media cited for comparison

Bach, J. S. (Composer). (n.d.). Toccata and Fugue in D minor [Musical composition].

DeVito, D. (Director). (1996). Matilda [Film]. TriStar Pictures.

De Vito, D. (Director). (2007). Feast of Love [Film]. MGM.

De Palma, B. (Director). (1980). The Shining [Film]. Warner Bros.

Disney, W. (Producer). (1996). 101 Dalmatians [Film]. Walt Disney Pictures.

Lorre, C., & Prady, B. (Creators). (2009). The Big Bang Theory (Season 3, Episode 4: The Spoiler Alert Segmentation) [TV series episode]. CBS.

Reed, A., & Thompson, M. (Creators). (2009). Archer (Season 5, Episode 2) [TV series episode]. FX.

Soloway, J. (Creator). (2014). Madam Secretary (Season 2, Episode 2: The Doability Doctrine) [TV series episode]. CBS.

Stone, O. (Director). (2016). Snowden official Comic‑Con trailer [Film trailer]. Open Road Films.

Tags: #TrueCrime #TrueCrimeCommunity #TrueCrimePodcast #LouisvilleKentucky #JamieCarroll #JeffreyMundt #JoeyBanis #MurderinGlitterballCity #OldLouisville #KentuckyTrueCrime #DragQueenMurder #Hitched2Homicide #RonicaReed #ColdCase #TrueCrimeAddict

Jamie Carroll murder Louisville Kentucky, Jeffrey Mundt, Joey Banis, Murder in Glitterball City, Old Louisville murder, 1435 South 4th Street Louisville, Ronica Reed drag queen murder, meth murder Louisville, Louisville true crime, Hitched 2 Homicide, he-said he-said murder trial Kentucky