Three Jolts to Justice: The Shocking Case of Michael G. Schiller
- KRIS CALVERT
- Apr 16
- 6 min read
Three Jolts to Justice: The Shocking Case of Michael G. Schiller
A brutal backyard murder. A courtroom drama. And an electric chair that just wouldn’t finish the job.
The Crime That Shocked Youngstown
On June 19, 1903, the quiet neighborhood of Youngstown, Ohio, was shattered by a crime so savage it still echoes through true crime history. Michael G. Schiller, a local saloon keeper with a taste for whiskey and rage, arrived at the home of his estranged wife, Mary Schiller. What unfolded in the backyard was not a domestic dispute—it was a slaughter.
Michael didn’t use poison or a pistol. He used a knife, plunging it into Mary’s abdomen and disemboweling her in a fit of rage. She died from the horrific wounds. The gruesome attack left three children without a mother, and, eventually, without a father.
Trial #1: A Courtroom Misstep
Schiller was swiftly arrested, indicted, and tried in the Mahoning County Court of Common Pleas. During the May Term of 1903, he was convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to death by electrocution.
But the Ohio Supreme Court stepped in. On appeal, they ruled that the trial judge failed to fully inform the jury that a recommendation of mercy would have meant life in prison without parole—not a possible future release. The court reversed the conviction, citing improper jury instructions. A legal technicality gave Michael G. Schiller one more chance to live.
Trial #2: The Jury Speaks Again
In May 1904, Michael Schiller stood trial once more. This time, the jury needed no clarification. They found him guilty without a recommendation of mercy. The death sentence was reinstated.
Schiller was transferred to the Ohio Penitentiary in Columbus, where he would meet a fate as violent and unforgiving as the one he inflicted.
The Execution That Wouldn't Stick
At 12:01 a.m. on July 17, 1904, Michael G. Schiller was led into the death chamber. Strapped into the state’s electric chair, he became one of Ohio’s earliest electrocutions. But the process was far from clean.
The first jolt of electricity surged through his body—but it didn’t kill him.
A second jolt followed. Still, Schiller lived.
It took a third and final surge of voltage before Michael Schiller was finally pronounced dead at 12:30 a.m., thirty minutes after his execution began. Witnesses described the scene as gruesome, chaotic, and deeply unsettling. The electric chair, designed to be swift and “humane,” had made a mess of justice.
Schiller’s case didn’t just shock the community—it forced Ohio to examine its execution methods and legal proceedings. It also left behind three orphaned children, a devastated town, and a story that would become whispered legend in Youngstown’s darker history.
End Notes
This story is a case study in legal failure, judicial reform, and the deeply flawed pursuit of "humane" execution. It's also a reminder of how rage, when left unchecked, can destroy families, communities, and even the systems designed to uphold justice.
Want More Cases Like This?
Subscribe to Hitched 2 Homicide wherever you get your podcasts, and never miss another deep dive into the dark, twisted, and unforgettable corners of true crime.
Follow us:
Follow H2H Join H2H In-laws and Outlaws: https://www.facebook.com/groups/h2hinlawsandoutlaws
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/hitched2homicide/
Twitter: https://twitter.com/H2H_Podcast
Listen on Spotify, Apple, or wherever you binge your murder stories. Or watch on YouTube.
sources used for this podcast:
Historical & Informational Web Sources
Find a Grave. (n.d.). Mary Schiller Memorial. https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/192345716/mary-schiller
Vindicator Archives. (2016, August 1). Couple takes interest in abandoned North Side home. https://vindyarchives.com/news/2016/aug/01/couple-takes-interest-in-abandoned-north/
Habsburger.net. (n.d.). Dual Monarchy: Two states, single empire. https://ww1.habsburger.net/en/chapters/dual-monarchy-two-states-single-empire
Historical Crime Detective. (n.d.). The most miraculous execution in American history that nobody told you about – 1904. https://www.historicalcrimedetective.com/the-most-miraculous-execution-in-american-history-that-nobody-told-you-about-1904/
Amazon. Famous Crimes the World Forgot by Jason Lucky Morrow Book purchase link. https://amzn.to/42gN51G
Newspaper Articles & Archives (via Newspapers.com)
Newspapers.com. (n.d.). Article on Michael G. Schiller. 11.6.1903 The Evening Review https://www.newspapers.com/image/62144474/?match=1&terms=Michael%20G.%20Schiller
Newspapers.com. (n.d.). Article on Michael G. Schiller. 7.31.1903 The Akron Beacon Journal https://www.newspapers.com/image/228105166/?match=1&terms=Michael%20G.%20Schiller
Newspapers.com. (n.d.). Article on Michael G. Schiller. 6.2.1903 The Cleveland Leader https://www.newspapers.com/image/1074547560/?match=1&terms=Michael%20G.%20Schiller
Newspapers.com. (n.d.). Article on Michael Schiller. 6.17.1904 The Cincinnati Post
Newspapers.com. (n.d.). Article on Michael G. Schiller. 10.20.1903 The Cleveland Press
Newspapers.com. (n.d.). Article on Michael G. Schiller. 6.9.1904 The Cleveland Press
Newspapers.com. (n.d.). Article on Michael G. Schiller. 6.17.1904 The Cleveland Press
Newspapers.com. (n.d.). Article on Michael G. Schiller. The Marion Daily Star
Newspapers.com. (n.d.). Article on Michael G. Schiller. 6.17.1904 The Cleveland Leader https://www.newspapers.com/image/1074710167/?match=1&terms=Michael%20G.%20Schiller
Newspapers.com. (n.d.). Article on Michael G. Schiller. 8.26.1903 The Dayton Herald
Newspapers.com. (n.d.). Article on Michael G. Schiller. 6.18.1904 The Plain Dealer https://www.newspapers.com/image/1074673817/?match=1&terms=Michael%20G.%20Schiller
Newspapers.com. (n.d.). Article on Michael G. Schiller. 12.20.1903 The Cincinnati Enquirer
Newspapers.com. (n.d.). Article on Michael G. Schiller. 4.21.1904 The Crestline Advocate
Newspapers.com. (n.d.). Article on Michael G. Schiller. 5.27.1904 The Cleveland Press
Newspapers.com. (n.d.). Article on Michael G. Schiller. 4.14.1904 The Plain Dealer
Newspapers.com. (n.d.). Article on Michael G. Schiller. 6.20.1904 The Akron Beacon Journal
Media & TV/Film Sources (APA Style)
Television Episodes:
Rhimes, S. (Writer), & Corn, R. (Director). (2010, November 18). Slow Night, So Long (Season 7, Episode 9) [TV series episode]. In Grey’s Anatomy. ABC.
Whedon, J. (Writer), & Mahoney, D. (Director). (2021, April 25). Ignition (Season 1, Episode 3) [TV series episode]. In The Nevers. HBO.
Marlowe, A. W. (Writer), & Bowman, R. (Director). (2009, March 9). Flowers for Your Grave (Season 1, Episode 1) [TV series episode]. In Castle. ABC.
Kohan, J. (Writer), & Trim, C. (Director). (2008, June 16). Mother Thinks the Birds Are After Her (Season 4, Episode 1) [TV series episode]. In Weeds. Showtime.
Flanagan, M. (Writer/Director). (2020, October 9). The Romance of Certain Old Clothes (Season 1, Episode 8) [TV series episode]. In The Haunting of Bly Manor. Netflix.
Spielman, J. (Writer), & Trilling, S. (Director). (2021, May 28). Daniel Espinoza: Naked and Afraid (Season 5, Episode 12) [TV series episode]. In Lucifer. Netflix.
Rake, J. (Writer), & Geiger, D. (Director). (2018, October 15). Connecting Flights (Season 1, Episode 5) [TV series episode]. In Manifest. NBC.
Judge, M. (Writer/Director). (1998, November 3). Peggy’s Headache (Season 3, Episode 3) [TV series episode]. In King of the Hill. FOX.
Brooks, J. L., Groening, M., & Simon, S. (Writers). (1995, November 26). Sideshow Bob’s Last Gleaming (Season 7, Episode 9) [TV series episode]. In The Simpsons. FOX.
MacFarlane, S. (Writer/Director). (2015, October 4). Papa Has a Rollin’ Son (Season 14, Episode 2) [TV series episode]. In Family Guy. FOX.
YouTube. (1968). Virginia Slims Ad 1968 [Video]. YouTube.
YouTube. (1982). Enjoli Perfume Ad 1982 [Video]. YouTube.
Films:
Mickelson, R. (Director). (1989). Who’s Harry Crumb? [Film]. Columbia Pictures.
Coraci, S. (Director). (2000). Little Nicky [Film]. New Line Cinema.
Darabont, F. (Director). (1999). The Green Mile [Film]. Warner Bros.Castle Rock Entertainment.
Spielberg, S. (Director). (2002). Catch Me If You Can [Film]. DreamWorks Pictures.
Whale, J. (Director). (1931). Frankenstein [Film]. Universal Pictures.
Gilliam, T., & Jones, T. (Directors). (1975). Monty Python and the Holy Grail [Film]. EMI Films.
Brooks, M. (Director). (1974). Blazing Saddles [Film]. Warner Bros.
Robert Zemeckis (Director). (1989). Back to the Future Part II [Film] Universal Pictures.
DISCLAIMER OF LIABILITY
All information contained in this audio podcast or video presentation is provided for entertainment purposes only. The authors leave any and all conclusions to individual members of the audience. The author offers no statements of fact beyond those available through diligent private research or through information freely available in the public record. To the extent that pending or settled criminal matters or crime or possible crimes, are discussed in this audio podcast or video presentation. All parties or defendants are presumed innocent unless proven guilty in a court of law. To the extent that any pending or settled civil matters are discussed in this video presentation, all parties or defendants are presumed not liable unless proven liable in a court of law. Copyright for material incorporated and presented under Fair Use is retained by the original author or copyright holder where applicable. Our cases are researched using open source and archive materials, and the subjects are real crimes and people. We strive to produce each episode with respect to the victims, their families and loved ones. At Hitched 2 Homicide we are committed to always discussing how victims lived, and not just how they died. All podcast information is gleaned from sources given. All opinions in the podcast are solely of Hitched 2 Homicide and are for entertainment purposes only.
Comments